CELPIP Speaking Task 5: Compare & Persuade
Choose one option and sell it with 2 strong reasons. Compare fairly, address one drawback, and finish with a clear recommendation.
What They Test
You are scored on clarity, organization, comparisons, and how convincingly you support your choice.
Clear Recommendation
Picking one option early and defending it directly (use “you” / “we”).
Strong Reasons
Giving 2 solid reasons (cost, time, quality, convenience) and making them concrete with a quick example.
Comparison Language
Using clear connectors (whereas, on the other hand, compared to) to show differences and benefits.
Persuasive Tone
Sounding confident and respectful (not aggressive). Acknowledge the other option briefly, then explain why your choice wins.
Template Phrases
Ready-to-use expressions that help you compare clearly and persuade confidently.
Opening + Choice
- “Honestly, I’d go with option A, and here’s why.”
- “I think we should choose A for two reasons...”
- “If you want the best result, A is the smarter choice.”
Comparing Options
- “Option A is …, whereas option B is …”
- “Compared to B, A is more …”
- “On the one hand…, but on the other hand…”
Reasons (Concrete Benefits)
- “That matters because it will save you…”
- “The biggest advantage is…, especially if…”
- “For example, last time…”
Address Drawback + Wrap Up
- “I know B has a good point, but…”
- “Even if…, A still makes more sense because…”
- “So overall, let’s choose A. It’s the more practical option.”
Sample Answer (60 seconds)
A Band 7–10 sample that compares quickly and persuades with 2 reasons.
Scenario:
You and your friend are deciding where to buy groceries: a supermarket or a farmers’ market. Persuade your friend to choose one option.
Opening + Choice:
“If you want better quality food without wasting money, I’d choose the farmers’ market. Two reasons are freshness and smarter spending.”
Reason 1 (Quality / Freshness):
“First, the produce is usually fresher, so it tastes better and lasts longer. For example, when I buy berries at the market, they stay good for days instead of going soft overnight.”
Reason 2 (Spending / Focus):
“Second, it’s easier to stick to a plan. At the supermarket, I end up adding random snacks. At the market, I buy what I actually need, so I spend less overall.”
Address the Other Option:
“I know the supermarket is more convenient, but if we go once a week with a short list, the farmers’ market is still the smarter choice.”
Wrap Up:
“So overall, let’s choose the farmers’ market. It’s more practical, and we’ll get better food for the same budget.”
Why This Response Scores High:
- Chooses one option clearly at the start
- Gives 2 strong reasons with a concrete example
- Uses comparison language without being negative
- Ends with a clear, persuasive wrap-up
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Avoid these frequent errors that lower scores on CELPIP Speaking Task 5.
Mistake 1: No Clear Choice
If you never choose one option clearly, your answer sounds unfocused.
Weak:
“Both options are good. It depends.”
Strong:
“I’d choose option A, and here are two clear reasons.”
Mistake 2: No Comparison Language
You need to show differences (cost, time, quality) with connectors like “whereas” and “compared to”.
Tip: Use a simple line: “A is better for X, whereas B is better for Y.”
Mistake 3: Aggressive / Negative Tone
Persuasion should sound respectful. Avoid attacking the other option or the listener.
Tip: Say “I see your point, but…” instead of “That’s a bad idea.”
Mini Quiz
Test your understanding of CELPIP Speaking Task 5 with these quick questions.
1. What is the primary purpose of CELPIP Speaking Task 5?
2. What is the best structure for Task 5?
3. What helps your persuasion sound natural?
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about CELPIP Speaking Task 5 answered.
Should I talk about both options?
Yes, but briefly. Mention one strength of the other option, then explain why your choice is better overall.
How many reasons do I need?
Aim for 2 strong reasons. If you have time, add one short counterpoint (a drawback of your choice and why it’s still okay).
What topics work well for reasons?
Use practical factors: cost, time, convenience, quality, safety, and long-term value.
How do I sound persuasive (not rude)?
Speak politely and directly: “I see your point, but…” and finish with a clear wrap-up: “So overall, let’s choose…”.